Deadmonton and the Other Things We Say

Written by Trinity Remple

When I moved here from Vernon last fall, one of the most common questions Edmontonians would ask me was “Why would you ever move to Edmonton?” It wasn’t necessarily the question itself that interested me, but rather the way people would ask. Like they felt bad for me. That caught me off guard. I grew up being proud of the intricacies that made my hometown unique, so hearing people talk down on their own city was new to me. Once I picked up on that tone, I started to hear it more often.

The usual complaints are that there’s nothing to do, it’s cold, and downtown is dead. I don’t want to fully dismiss those, but I also think the criticism might be harsher than the city deserves.

We all carry impressions of places: Paris is romantic, New York is fast and intense. Unfortunately, somewhere along the way, Edmonton was labelled as boring. At its core, this isn’t an argument about people or culture (which I’ll note is much more diverse and lively than where I moved from); it’s an argument about urban form. Edmonton really is built around the car, and that shapes how the city feels.

I’m not saying Edmonton deserves a free pass, but it was shaped by the conditions it grew up in, like the endless prairie land, postwar oil booms and a prioritization of car infrastructure. So when people say “there’s nothing to do,” there’s often plenty. It’s just that each experience is watered down by a 30-minute drive and the joy of six laps around the parking lot.

Call me optimistic, but after further thought, I wonder if people are so hard on Edmonton because they care. Maybe it’s because they see what the city could be and are holding out for its potential. And to be honest, I think there is a lot worth celebrating, like the river valley, the mix of festivals that come to town each year, and streets like 104th and Whyte.

I’m not trying to say Edmonton is perfect, but maybe the way we talk about it has real consequences for the city. If we constantly describe a place as “dead,” doesn’t that make people more reluctant to visit? Not to mention, the people trying to improve the city may start to feel damned if they do and damned if they don’t. So maybe next time someone asks you what living in Edmonton is like, be real, but don’t forget to mention some of the good too.

Written by Trinity Remple

Sources

Cover photo

Justin Hu on Unsplash

Previous
Previous

If You Work Hard, Can You Reach the Moon?

Next
Next

No tap fare? No fair. An Edmontonian's thoughts on Calgary’s CTrain